Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Carl Karasti's avatar

Thanks for another well-written sharing of your thoughts, Eli.

From my perspective, I don't think "It's difficult to grasp how a moment like this could come to pass." What is difficult, though, is accepting what brought this upon us. As with all of the political troubles we've had, the fault lies with We the People, for not being engaged in the process of keeping our republic. This is just the current manifestation of the waves of troubles we have brought upon ourselves after decades, a couple of generations, of neglecting our rights, responsibilities and privileges as citizens of a representative democracy. We have had "government of the people," but the "by the people" part has been very weak, which has resulted in the "for the people" part also being very weak.

We have paid a lot of attention to the freedoms that define our nation and that we desire so dearly, but we have neglected and even been in denial of the concomitant responsibilities that are inherent in these freedoms. And there are great responsibilities that are essential to keeping freedoms, particularly when considering that these freedoms must truly be for all rather than for just a few. This also doesn't mean just for all people, it means for all beings, all ways of being, including the plants, the animals, the microbes, and even the beings we typically consider to be non-living such as the stones, water, air .... all and everything that is part of Mother Earth. We have been focused on personal freedoms to take and ignored or denied responsibilities to give to maintain.

You say "there is still time to change course, to learn from history rather than repeat it" yet we don't know this and we do know that we may have seriously limited our time to change and do better. With the exploitation of non-renewable resources, our disrespect for the Natural world, our human-powered climate change, our disrespect for ourselves and each other, we may have already been inexorably on our way to a greatly accelerated self-demise that may now become even further accelerated.

Long ago I participated in organizing the first ever Earth Day event at the University of Minnesota, Duluth. Our awareness and concern about our environmental impacts was suddenly becoming deeper, broader and more widely spread and many of us were trying to spread the knowledge and understanding even more widely. Over the ensuing 54 years the scope of our collective knowledge, understanding and concern has expanded greatly, yet our actual progress in stemming our negative impacts has been tiny in the scope of the huge issue We the People have created and continued to exacerbate. Yes, we have made some progress, but we have also continued to make our problems more serious and more widespread. The Pogo comic from way back then has made little difference in the observation that "We have met the enemy and they are us." We the People, collectively, continue to be our own enemy in many ways: politically, socially, environmentally, economically, religiously. The next administration in our White House will not make it any easier to do what needs to be done and they will likely expand on what needs to be done to recover.

"The challenges ahead" have always been daunting ... because it doesn't take much to daunt us. I'm sorry that my generation has been so daunted. I sincerely hope that your generation will not be. Humans could do a lot better than we have been so far. After all, we named ourselves Homo sapiens – we are supposed to be wise, able to make wise choices, able to survive ourselves. Many have deemed the dinosaurs "failures" because they went extinct – apparently thinking they were "losers" but they were around for about 145 million years before they got wiped out. Compared to them, we humans have barely gotten here, having been around for around 7 million years. We still have a long ways to go.... Best wishes!

Expand full comment

No posts